How to Choose the Right Raw Feeding Model

How to Choose the Right Raw Feeding Model

Embracing raw feeding for dogs means stepping into a world where we mimic their ancestral diet, balancing muscle meat, organs, bones, and plant matter.

A raw feeding model offers a framework for pet owners to construct a diet that resembles a dog's natural eating habits. From the initial Prey Model to the later developed BARF (Biologically Appropriate Raw Food) model and other variations, these guidelines have evolved to meet diverse canine dietary needs.

Raw feeding models are beneficial because they:

  • Provide a starting point for transitioning to raw or DIY raw diets.
  • Represent an effort to replicate a dog's natural diet, despite the lack of consensus on precise nutritional requirements.
  • Serve as a recipe, outlining the proportions of each dietary component.

1. Premade Raw Dog Food:

This option involves commercially prepared raw meals, ideal for beginners due to its convenience and balanced formulation.


  • Balanced diet without the need for extensive nutritional knowledge.
  • Access to a variety of proteins and formulations.
  • Convenient and mess-free feeding.
  • Availability of home delivery options from some brands.


  • High-pressure pasteurization used by some brands can be controversial.
  • Generally more expensive due to packaging and formulation costs.
  • Potential use of synthetic vitamins and non-organic sourcing in some brands.
  • Not all brands cater to puppies or specific life stages.

2. Prey Model Raw Feeding:

This model aims to replicate a wild canine's diet, focusing on whole prey consumption without fruits, vegetables, or supplements.


  • Closely mirrors the natural diet of wild canines.
  • Encourages natural chewing behavior and dental health.
  • Promotes slower, more mindful eating.


  • May lack certain nutrients like Omega-3 fatty acids and vitamins.
  • Requires additional freezer space for whole prey items.
  • Can be messy and challenging for some owners.

3. BARF Model Raw Feeding:

Developed by Dr. Ian Billinghurst, this model includes a wider variety of foods, including vegetables and fruits, for a more balanced approach.


  • More accessible nutrient spectrum through the inclusion of plant matter.
  • Ground raw feeding option is easier to manage.
  • Flexible in terms of ingredient choices.


  • Faster consumption with ground raw may miss out on dental benefits.
  • Potential need for additional freezer space.
  • Some dogs may refuse vegetables.

4. Ancestral Diet Model:

Inspired by the diets of ancestral canines, this model includes a balanced mix of meats, seafood, and minimal plant matter.


  • Comprehensive nutrient profile including seafood for Omega-3 fatty acids.
  • Flexibility in combining whole and ground ingredients.


  • Requires adequate storage for diverse ingredients.

5. Rotational MonoFeeding (RMF):

This newer model, inspired by Nora Lenz, emphasizes feeding meat, vegetables, and fasting on a rotational basis.


  • Incorporates fasting for digestive health.
  • Easier meal prep with a primary focus on plant-based nutrition.


  • May not meet all nutritional needs without careful planning.
  • Limited supplementation and bone broth use.

Choosing the Right Model for Your Dog:

Selecting the appropriate raw feeding model depends on your dog's needs, your lifestyle, and resources.

I've found a modified approach, blending elements from BARF, Prey, Ancestral, and RMF models, to be most effective for my dogs. This flexibility allows me to adapt to their evolving nutritional needs and changes in our circumstances.

Sourcing Ingredients:

Finding quality ingredients is crucial in raw feeding. Potential sources include raw food co-ops, outlet grocery stores, restaurant supply stores, local farms, and ethnic grocery stores.

For seafood, consider outlet stores, Real Dog Box, and co-ops. Fur, feathers, and vegetables can be sourced from specialty suppliers, container gardens, farmers' markets, and local farms.

In Summary

Raw feeding models provide valuable guidelines but should be adapted to suit individual dogs. Ongoing education and openness to new ideas are key to successfully nourishing your dog with a raw diet.

Whether you choose premade options for convenience or dive into DIY raw feeding, the priority is your dog's health and happiness. Remember, there's no one-size-fits-all approach to raw feeding, so be prepared to tailor these models to best fit your dog's unique needs and your lifestyle.

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.